Neutral Evolution vs. Evolution by Natural Selection

Kimura’s theory of neutral evolution states that many mutations are synonymous and do not get selected for/against because it does not have any effect on the phenotype of the organism. These neutral mutations will become fixed in the population at a ready rate. If there is deviation from that rate, there is a nonsynonymous mutation present that is being selected on.

            The theory of evolution by natural selection states that organisms with different traits have differential rates of survival. The ones that survive and are able to reproduce the most will pass their traits down to their offspring. Eventually, the beneficial trait will become more common in the population.

            Both theories of evolution have the same end result: traits that affect the phenotype will be selected on. The difference between them is that Kimura’s theory focused on genetics on a molecular level, whereas the natural selection focuses more on genetics on the level of how it affects the entire organism interacting with its environment. Because the mechanisms of genetics were not known when the theory of evolution by natural selection came about, scientists had to rely on what they could observe with the naked eye. Somebody like Darwin would’ve had no idea that there were many more mutations occurring that he could not observe because they were neutral.

            Each theory gives different benefits. Kimura’s theory of neutral evolution allows scientists to use mutations as a molecular clock. Additionally, by comparing the numbers of nonsynonymous mutations to the numbers of synonymous mutations, it can be determined whether positive, negative, or no selection is acting. The theory that involves natural selection is useful because it allows people to see the phenotype that the gene produces and gives us a better understanding as to why that allele is beneficial or harmful in that environment.

            In summary, the theories are more alike than different. Conceptually, they are very similar. However, they focus on different aspects of science such as molecular genetics vs. behavior in an environment. It is clear that these theories were greatly shaped by the information and technology available to the scientists at that time.

Comments

  1. Kathleen, great post! That distinction between molecular genetics and environmental behavior is an important one. I think you hit the nail on the head with your comment on the similarities between the two. I think Darwin definitely may have considered neutral evolution in his theories if he had had the technology and knowledge of today.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Man, I didn't even think about the applicational differences between these two theories. Nice catch, man! It's pretty cool, now that I think about it, that we effectively have another null model for evolution. Aside from using it as a benchmark, do you think the "neutral" part of "neutral evolution theory" is important? Can something evolve neutrally? The word implies a lack of important change, but evolution implies change, soooo....?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I guess it means we evolve but it does not affect our fitness. I see what you mean.

      Delete
  3. This is a fantastic post Kathleen! I specifically enjoyed your inclusion of Darwin in your discussion as this is an aspect I failed to implement in my comparison of these unique theories. In addition to this, your application of the molecular clock to Kimura's theory of neutral evolution is well explicated and utilizing this aspect in conjunction with the theory of evolution based on natural selection provides a hybrid theory of evolution that may be even more accurate than the theories when analyzed separately. This was one of the best posts I have read thus far in the semester so great work!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

"Fitness" in Biology

Natural Selection and Evolution