Natural Selection and Evolution

A common misconception is that natural selection is evolution. In reality, natural selection is just one of several mechanisms through which evolution can occur. In fact, natural selection may not even lead to evolution in some instances. As Dr. Tobler pointed out in his video “Testing Darwin’s Postulates in Nature”, natural selection can occur within one generation, but evolution is something that must span multiple generations.

For example, when the massive drought hit the Galapagos Islands, many small beaked finches died due to natural selection. This lead the average beak size of the population to decrease. At first glance, this may appear to be evolution through natural selection, but this change in the population occurred within one generation. In order to call it evolution, the change in the gene pool must persist in the subsequent generations. If beak size was not a heritable trait, the average beak size would probably go back to what it was before in the subsequent generations. This is important to point out as it relates back to another of Darwin’s postulates: traits must be heritable in order for evolution to occur. Therefore, any natural selection that is selecting on nonheritable traits cannot lead to the evolution of that trait in subsequent generations. 

As mentioned early, natural selection is not the only mechanism through which evolution can occur. One of the most obvious causes of evolution, besides natural selection, is sexual selection. This would include any traits that helps an animal reproduce higher numbers of offspring. There are countless examples in nature: colorful plumage on birds, large horns on goats, full manes on lions, loud mating calls from whales, and bright lights on fireflies. All of these things can increase an animal’s ability to mate and increase offspring. Those traits, if heritable, will become increasingly common in subsequent generations; thus, producing evolution. 





Comments

  1. I've always found it interesting that sexual selection can have a larger impact on the evolution of a species than natural selection. Like your example of bird plumages, those brightly colored plumages not only attract mates but also make the bird stand out more for predators yet birds continue to have colorful plumages instead of duller plumages that would help camouflage the birds from predators.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Kathleen! I found your blog post to be very insightful and helped me fill in some gaps in my thinking that I did not hit on in my blog post. I really liked how you addressed what Dr. Tobler had said in his video bout how evolution takes several generation to occur, while natural selection can happen fairly quickly and within the span of one generation. Relating these terms back to the R Studio exercise was also very helpful because I misunderstood it the first time.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

"Fitness" in Biology

Neutral Evolution vs. Evolution by Natural Selection