Lamarck's Evolution
Science is a field of trial and error. One of the most important aspects that allows the progression of our knowledge are brave people who put an idea out there that no one has ever thought of before. Jean Baptiste Lamarck had some revolutionary ideas about evolution. Today, we know that some of those ideas were incorrect. However, Lamarck’s theories still did a lot for the study of evolution. They allowed people of the time to look at things in a new light and open their minds to new possibilities and a new way of thinking.
Lamarck’s theory that organisms are not fixed being, and may change over time in response to their environments was spot-on. However, he misunderstood the mechanism of change. Lamarck proposed that this change could occur within the lifespan of the animal due to its behavior, and then could be passed down to its offspring. In reality, change occurs over the span of generations. An organism’s DNA remains the same from birth, regardless of the behaviors of the animal (disregarding mutations). The organism itself doesn’t change, it’s a matter of the organism already possessing a trait that allows it to survive and reproduce better than the other organisms of that population. This knowledge would not have been attainable without the field of genetics, and more knowledge about our DNA and the heritability of traits. Considering the time period Lamarck developed his theory, he did very well with the information that was available to him.
Another aspect of Lamarck’s theory was that organisms evolved in a linear progression, from simplest to most complex. Using this theory, it could be wrongly assumed that bacteria and other microbes are the newest life forms, whereas complex organisms like humans or other mammals are the most ancient. Even today, many people have the misconception that evolution is striving for the “best”, most complex life form. Today, it can be said that evolution does not in fact have a strong correlation with complexity. Many bacteria were some of the first life forms on earth, and have remained practically unchanged for millions of years. One cannot make a broad statement such as “animals evolve to become increasingly complex”. A more accurate statement would be “animals evolve to become successful in their environment”. A great example of this is that at one point, snakes actually had legs. Then, it became more advantageous to not have legs in that environment. Eventually the legs became vestigial.
Much respect and admiration is owed to scientists like Jean Baptiste Lamarck, who spent his life developing his own ideas about evolution. It is easy to look back and his ideas and scoff at them, but that is only because of the advances we have made in the field of genetics. Considering the current understanding of DNA and inheritance at the time (which was very little), his ideas were advanced and not too far off from the truth. In science, sometimes being wrong can be just as valuable as being right.
Comments
Post a Comment