Can Mutations Rates Evolve?

            Any variation between organisms can be traced back to the mutation of one or more nucleotides in the DNA. Generally we tend to think of mutations as a bad thing that may cause cancer or cause a baby to be born with 6 fingers on each hand. In reality, mutations are essential to evolution. Without it, populations couldn’t accumulate enough mutations to diverge into new species, and all organisms on earth would be the same.

            As seen in the data presented in Dr. Tobler’s lecture “Mutation and Mutation Types”, organisms with larger genomes and larger bodies tend to have higher mutation rates. For example, E. coli has a rate of 0.0025 mutations per genome per generation, whereas humans have a rate of 1.6000 mutations per genome per generation. This makes sense because complex organisms have many more cell divisions in their lifetime, which gives many opportunities for mutations to occur.

            What else can affect mutation rates? Is it possible for the rate of mutations to evolve? In cancers, mutations begin to accumulate at an exponential rate because many of the proofreading mechanisms of the cell have been bypassed. This is definitely not a positive occurrence, and it could not be considered “evolution” because it is occurring within one individual in one generation. I don’t think mutation rates evolve to increase because our cells are designed to keep mutations at a minimum. Many mutations either have no effect on the body or will harm the body. It is very lucky if an individual gets a mutation that gives them an advantage.

            However, I can hypothesize one situation in which mutation rates would decrease over generations. If an individual gets a mutation that makes DNA replication even more accurate, that individual would be less likely to die of cancer and more likely to pass their genes to offspring. If a beneficial mutation such as this kept occurring, it could eventually lead to lower mutation rates in that population. In this case, that would be adaptive because less individuals would become ill with cancer.

Comments

  1. One thing to keep in mind about your hypothesis about a decrease in mutation rates being beneficial because cancer may be less prevalent is that most cancers don't actually come about until old age. Why would this be important for evolution? Would cancer as an older adult affect the number or quality of your offspring (i.e., your fitness)?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good point! I had not considered that. While females are often past childbearing age by the time they develop cancer, men do not have the same limitations. Theoretically, it could still increase the fitness of males in the population if they have a longer lifespan and have more time to reproduce. Additionally, maybe this hypothesis could still be applicable to other species of animals that tend to get cancer while still in a reproducing stage of life. Lastly, in organisms that care for their young for longer periods of time after offspring are born, it could give an advantage if the parent is protected from cancer and can survive long enough to raise their offspring. The offspring would be more likely to survive and pass on their genes.

      Delete
  2. Hi Kathleen, great post! Your point about more complex organisms having more mutations because they have larger genomes makes sense. Are the numbers you mentioned for human and E. coli mutation rates already adjusted for size of genome? I think higher mutation rates might have a larger evolutionary advantage in simpler organisms, so is it possible that E. coli have higher relative mutation rates even if they have fewer total mutations?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, Tom. Those were numbers given in Dr. Tobler's lecture about mutation rates. I believe he said that both a larger body size and a larger genome size would increase the mutation rates. The frequencies were based on the average number of mutations per genome per generation. I'm not sure about the relative number of mutation rates. That's a great question!

      Delete
  3. Hi Kathleen,
    I really appreciate your explanation of mutation rates when it comes to e coli and humans. I have been having trouble understanding what was meant by mutation rates, but this blog post gives me a really clear understanding!

    The only thing I can think of to question is mutation rates being mostly bad for the individual. I think there can be just as many good mutation as bad mutations but it depends on the way you are looking at it. I have watched quite a few documentaries on someone who had a gene mutation that has made their lives very different from a "normal" person but to them they are in no way disadvantaged. Maybe those mutations are actually benefiting people in a way unseen because society likes to think of different as a bad thing when it could actually be beneficial!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Mariah,

      I agree that in humans, mutations can be a lot less destructive, but I was thinking more along the lines of animals in the wild and natural selection. As humans, we provide a lot of healthcare and accommodations for those with different needs, but animals with disfiguring mutations are much more likely to die before being able to reproduce.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

"Fitness" in Biology

Neutral Evolution vs. Evolution by Natural Selection

Natural Selection and Evolution